Friday, October 9, 2026
type here...
Enthusiast Report
Enthusiast Report
Cigar Ratings

WELCOME TO OUR NEW RATINGS GUIDE PLEASE NOTE WE ARE UNDER CONSTRUCTION AND CURRENTLY UPDATING 

Enthusiast Report • Cigar Ratings

Cigar Ratings Index

BrandCigarDate RatedRating
Asylum 13PandemoniumOctober 7, 202689
La Flor DominicanaSuave MaceoOctober 7, 202690
2024 Ferio TegoGenerosoOctober 7, 202694
Alec BradleyBlack MarketOctober 7, 202691
IllusioneJeremy Piven Collection PIVOctober 7, 202681
DavidoffAVO Classic MaduroSeptember 30, 202690
MontecristoPetit No. 2September 30, 202686
C.L.E.Corojo 11/18September 30, 202693
Rocky PatelVintage 1990September 30, 202692
La Gloria CubanaClassico MaduroSeptember 30, 202689
Warped CigarsOne Cloud Hopper No. 53September 23, 202692
AshtonAged Maduro No.60September 23, 202687
WildfireRadio-OctaveSeptember 23, 202693
Raises CubanasClassicSeptember 23, 202692
OlivaConnecticut ReserveSeptember 23, 202688
MBombayKesaraSeptember 21, 202690
FratelloBiancoSeptember 16, 202690
Gurka VBy Oscar ValladaresSeptember 16, 202692
Brick HouseBricktoberfest 2026September 16, 202693
Room 10117th AnniversarySeptember 16, 202693
TatuajeCohete CorojoSeptember 9, 202690
La Aurora115th AnniversarySeptember 9, 202693
PlasenciaCosecha 151 La MusicaSeptember 9, 202694
La GaleraMaduro PresidenteSeptember 9, 202691
Illusione CigarsEpernay Le MondeSeptember 9, 202688
Oscar ValladaresColaboraciones – Oliva CigarsSeptember 2, 202693
TrinidadTommy Bahama Island CollectionSeptember 2, 202693
Padrón1926 Serie No. 6September 2, 202696
Romeo y Julieta -Reserva Real Nicaragua ProfundoSeptember 2, 202692
West Tampa Tobacco Co.Chef RickSeptember 2, 202691
OlivaSeries OAugust 26, 202689
NaturaThird HarvestAugust 26, 202691
Arturo FuenteDon CarlosAugust 26, 202692
La Aroma de CubaConneticutAugust 26, 202687
StoicEquinimityAugust 26, 202692
Rocky PatelYear of the HorseAugust 19, 202692
KristoffNicaraguaAugust 19, 202691
My FatherNo. 2August 19, 202689
DavidoffSignature 2000August 19, 202690
HVCLa DecoraciónAugust 19, 202691
Aganorsa LeafSupreme LeafAugust 12, 202685
El SeptimoCulinary Art Collection France BordeauxAugust 12, 202689
Arturo FuenteRare Pink Vintage 1960's Short StoryAugust 12, 202692
Dunbarton Tobacco & TrustMi Querida Ancho LargoAugust 12, 202691
Montecristo90th Anniversary No. 2August 12, 202686
Esteban CarrerasConnecticut 12 YearAugust 5, 202687
RoMa CraftMaestranza Ciutadella CataloniaAugust 5, 202689
Black Label Trading Co.Bishop's Blend 2026August 5, 202694
J.C. NewmanPerla Del Mar CorojoAugust 5, 202691
CaldwellBlind Man's Bluff ConnecticutAugust 5, 202688
La AuroraPreferidos Double Barrel Aged PerfectoJuly 29, 202690
PadronSeries 1926 No. 1 MaduroJuly 29, 202693
Drew EstateUndercrown El TigreJuly 29, 202693
Epic CigarsSan Andres ProjectJuly 29, 202692
Montecristo1935 Anniversary Nicaragua No. 2July 29, 202688
J.C. NewmanPerla Del Mar ShadeJuly 22, 202685
TatuajeFausto FT110July 22, 202690
E.P. Carrila No. 62Inch MaduroJuly 22, 202690
My FatherLa LealtadJuly 22, 202692
HVCSeleccion No. 1 Short connecticutJuly 22, 202689
H. UpmannSunriseJuly 15, 202686
DavidoffPuro DominincanoJuly 15, 202689
Rocky PatelSapphireJuly 15, 202691
PlasenciaTriunfalJuly 15, 202694
PadronFamily Reserve no.85 MaduroJuly 15, 202695
La SirenaSuper Sea MonkeyJuly 8, 202693
7-20-4Series by K.AJuly 8, 202689
Ferio Tego SummaSummaJuly 8, 202693
Casa Torrent1942July 8, 202689
Alex BradleyKintsugiJuly 8, 202687
La SirenaOrginal The PrinceJuly 8, 202692
Crowned HeadsBroadwayJuly 1, 202689
FoundationOlmecJuly 1, 202693
J.C. NewmanThe AmericanJuly 1, 202692
DavidoffMaduroJuly 1, 202689
Epic CigarMaduroJuly 1, 202692
Viva La VidaConneticutJune 24, 202688
OlivaSeries VJune 24, 202692
Hiram and SolomonFraternal FlameJune 24, 202693
CruxPassportJune 24, 202690
Sancho Panza (Cuba)BelicosoJune 24, 202694
Natura CigarsPetit AlturaJune 17, 202692
Arturo FuenteDon Carlos Sangre de Toro Raging BullJune 17, 202690
TimelessPanamericaJune 17, 202693
CamachoTriple MaduroJune 17, 202689
La GaleraConneticutJune 17, 202688
CAOArcana StokkJune 10, 202686
Villiger 1888Gran ReservaJune 10, 202689
Black Label Trading Co.MacabreJune 10, 202693
Punch PunchCubanJune 10, 202691
Saint Luis ReyReserva Especial MaduroJune 10, 202684
Casa CarilloPledge PurpleJune 3, 202688
Room 101Johnny Tobacconaut MaduroJune 3, 202693
Dunbarton Tobacco & TrustMi QueridaJune 3, 202693
La AuroraFamily Creed PerserveranciaJune 3, 202692
PadronBlack PB-99 NaturalJune 3, 202689
Micallef'A'May 27, 202686
AstonSymmetry PrismMay 27, 202692
Arturo FuenteDon Carlos No.4May 27, 202693
A.J. Fernandez20th AnniversaryMay 27, 202690
GurkhaGhost AsuraMay 27, 202683
C.L.E.HabanoMay 20, 202687
FratelloNavetta DiscoveryMay 20, 202691
Alec Bradley30 YearMay 20, 202693
EspinosaKnuckle Sandwich HabanoMay 20, 202692
TatuajeBroadleaf Reserva Havana CazadoresMay 20, 202691
EpicLa Rubia ChurchillMay 14, 202690
La Aurora100 Anos Edicion EspecialMay 14, 202691
JM TobaccoEspanola 30 Aniversario MaduroMay 14, 202694
PatagasMaduro No.3May 14, 202687
MatildeLimited Exposure No. 3May 14, 202690
PerdomoLegacy Connecticut ChurchillMay 8, 202688
TrinidadSpecial Edition Tommy Bahama ToroMay 8, 202692
Plasencia151 Cosecha San DiegoMay 8, 202693
Cavalier GenèveBroadleaf CowriderMay 8, 202688
Romeo y Julieta - Altadis USAReserva Real Nicaragua Profundo ToroMay 8, 202689
DavidoffPuro DominicanaApril 29, 202693
Nat CiccoAniversario 1965April 29, 202693
La Flor DominicanaCarbon FlowerApril 29, 202695
West TampaCircle of LifeApril 29, 202690
Arturo FuenteDon Carlos 90 AnosApril 22, 202695
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust10th JubileeApril 8, 202693
Aging RoomQuattro Nicaragua Concerto VibratoApril 8, 202687
J.C. NewmanBrick HouseApril 8, 202692
Southern DrawDesert RoseApril 1, 202687
La PalinaMiami BabeApril 1, 202690
Hiram & SolomonShrinerApril 1, 202693
Alec BradleyPrensadoApril 1, 202694
ZinoNicaragua Half CoronaMarch 25, 202687
La Flor DominicanaOro No. 7March 25, 202691
CohibaMaduro 5 Genios (Cuban)March 25, 202688
Arturo FuenteOpusX Forbidden X Amor SensualMarch 25, 202694
Rocky PatelLB1March 18, 202690
DavidoffGrand Cru No.2March 18, 202688
CamachoConnecticutMarch 18, 202686
AshtonHeritage Puro SolMarch 18, 202693
AJ FernandezNasser The GoatMarch 18, 202695
Room 101Farce "It Is"March 11, 202693
Leaf by OscarCorojoMarch 11, 202693
H. UpmannVintage CameroonMarch 11, 202686
EspinosaHabanoMarch 11, 202692
TatuajeBoris KarloffMarch 4, 202694
La Aurora100 Años Edición Especial MaduroMarch 4, 202691
Joya de NicaraguaSilverMarch 4, 202691
FoundationAksum ClaroMarch 4, 202693
Casa CarrilloConnecticutMarch 4, 202687
Villiger1888 Gran ReservaFebruary 25, 202693
PunchKnuckle BusterFebruary 25, 202689
Natura CigarsAltura 1st HarvestFebruary 25, 202695
MontecristoNo.2 CubanFebruary 25, 202694
BentleyGreen EditionFebruary 25, 202689
Padron2000February 18, 202691
La Flor DominicanaLigero OscuroFebruary 18, 202689
Bariay 1492Red LabelFebruary 18, 202691
Drew EstateHerrera Estelí NorteñoFebruary 10, 202694
IllusioneOneOff Black & TanFebruary 10, 202692
KristoffSan AndrésFebruary 10, 202692
AshtonVirgin Sun Grown SorcererFebruary 10, 202689
PlasenciaAlma del CieloFebruary 4, 202692
Crowned HeadsBlood MedicineFebruary 4, 202687
Cavalier GenèveBroadleaf WayfinderFebruary 4, 202691
Arturo FuenteRosado Sungrown Magnum RFebruary 4, 202689
AJ FernandezNew World DecenioFebruary 4, 202691
PartagásSerie P No.2January 28, 202695
GurkhaCellar Reserve 21 YearJanuary 28, 202691
Casa CarrilloEncore BlackJanuary 28, 202689
Black Label Trading Co.Super DeluxeJanuary 28, 202693
Alec BradleyChunk Maduro XLJanuary 28, 202688
NotoriousThe Notorious Cigar by Conor McGregorDecember 31, 202593
OlivaSerie ODecember 31, 202588
Joya de NicaraguaClásicoDecember 31, 202590
Hiram & SolomonGrand ArchitectDecember 31, 202592
Arturo FuenteRare Pink Vintage 1960’sDecember 31, 202593
CLEMaduroDecember 17, 202592
La Gloria CubanaCorojo De OroDecember 17, 202592
J.C. NewmanDiamond Crown Maximus No. 4December 17, 202594
El PulpoThe EelDecember 17, 202591
AshtonAged Maduro No. 30December 17, 202589
Epic CigarA Bronx Tale "Sonny"December 10, 202592
West TampaDark TimeDecember 10, 202589
CamachoCorojo ChurchillDecember 10, 202593
Aging RoomLa Bohemia Pittore RobustoDecember 10, 202588
Arturo FuenteDon Carlos ‘The Man’December 3, 202591
My FatherFonsecaDecember 3, 202589
Arturo FuenteDon Carlos 'The Man'December 3, 202591
Aganorsa LeafRare Leaf ReserveDecember 3, 202592
RoMa CraftIntemperanceNovember 26, 202589
Foundation10 yr AnniversarioNovember 26, 202596
DavidoffYamasáNovember 26, 202592
Cavalier GenèveBII Viso JalapaNovember 26, 202591
AtabeyBlack RiosNovember 26, 202593
PadronPB99 MaduroNovember 19, 202596
OlivaSerie GNovember 19, 202588
MontecristoEpic Vintage 12 No. 2November 19, 202586
La Flor DominicanaLa NoxNovember 19, 202591
J.C. NewmanThe AmericanNovember 19, 202592
JM TobaccoEspanola MaduroNovember 12, 202593
Miami Cigar Co.Gran Reserva 2024November 12, 202592
Oscar ValledaresIsland Jim Barber Pole #2November 12, 202592
Drew EstateLiga Privada No.9November 12, 202595
CaldwellLa Barbera PurpleNovember 12, 202591
My FatherCedros DeluxeNovember 11, 202588
Rocky PatelConvictionNovember 5, 202595
Natura CigarsAkhal-TekeNovember 5, 202592
Bariay 1492Black LabelNovember 5, 202592
Arturo FuenteChateau Fuente PyramidNovember 5, 202589
Don LidoAfrica KuduOctober 29, 202593
Room101Big PaybackOctober 29, 202593
PadronDamaso No.12October 29, 202589
H. UpmannBanker DaytraderOctober 29, 202586
Don DoroteoEl Vencedor 1942October 29, 202594
PlasenciaAlma del FuegoOctober 22, 202595
MacanudoEmissary FranceOctober 22, 202590
KristoffShade GrownOctober 22, 202592
KristoffGuardrailOctober 22, 202593
FoundationWise Man CorojoOctober 22, 202595
CohibaRubiconOctober 22, 202590
Casa CarrilloEssence SumatraOctober 22, 202588
CAOAmazon Basin Extra AñejoOctober 22, 202590
Black Label Trading Co.ElettoOctober 22, 202591
ArtistaFalu BroadleafOctober 22, 202592
WarpedNicotinaOctober 15, 202591
Vicente BlendsPalladium VOctober 15, 202593
TatuajeEscasos HCOctober 15, 202594
J.C. NewmanAngel CuestaOctober 15, 202595
La Aurora120 Anniversary EditionOctober 2, 202592
Hiram & SolomonVeiled ProphetOctober 2, 202591
IllusioneOneOffSeptember 17, 202592
J.C. NewmanEl BatonSeptember 10, 202590
Drew EstateBlackened M84September 9, 202593
KristoffSumatraSeptember 8, 202593
Room101Farce HabanoSeptember 3, 202593
Casa 1910SampetrinaAugust 22, 202591
BlancoPrince Hall MaduroAugust 22, 202589
Don DoroteoSalt of the Earth PieAugust 20, 202591
Drew EstateBlackened M81August 15, 202595
La AuroraFamily Creed Series Feunte SolAugust 13, 202593
TributaryAureliusAugust 13, 202592
Rocky PatelEmeraldAugust 13, 202593
Nat CiccoFifty FiveAugust 13, 202592
La SirenaSuper Sea MonkeyAugust 13, 202594
KrisstoffConnecticutAugust 5, 202591
Natura CigarsSecond HarvestJuly 23, 202592
Cavalier GenèveJalapa ToroJune 18, 202591
Hiram & SolomonAshlar 10th AnniversaryJune 17, 202594
La AuroraPreferidos 1903 Platinum TuboJune 11, 202592
Room10115th AnniversaryMay 28, 202594
Nat CiccoAniversario 1965May 1, 202593
Davidoff"Winston Churchill" StatesmanApril 25, 202594
My FatherLe Bijou 1922April 16, 202593
J.C. NewmanDiamond Crown Julius CaesarMarch 21, 202594
Hiram & SolomonUnityDecember 12, 202492
Rocky PatelWhite LabelDecember 12, 202493
ArtistHarvestDecember 12, 202490
MatildeSerenaDecember 12, 202490
Room 10114th AnniversaryDecember 12, 202492
MatildeQuadatraDecember 12, 202492
Alec BradleyFine and Rare BCN-143December 12, 202491
PartagasValle VerdeDecember 12, 202489
El SeptimoBotticelliDecember 12, 202494
Illusione CigarsOrginal Documents CorojoDecember 12, 202491
El ReyDel Mundo Shade GrownDecember 12, 202489
J.C. NewmanPerla Del Mar ShadeDecember 12, 202491
Aganorsa LeafLa Validation ConnecticutDecember 12, 202491
JRE TobaccoAladino CameroonDecember 12, 202489
JM TobaccoEspañola Belicoso ConnecticutDecember 12, 202490
CAOPilon AnejoDecember 12, 202490
Ross Family CigarRick RossDecember 12, 202495
Nat CiccoCasino RealDecember 12, 202492
Illusione CigarsHabanoDecember 12, 202492
KristoffTres CompadresDecember 12, 202493
La Flor DominicanaLigero OscuroDecember 12, 202491
Miami CigarNestor Miranda Special SelectionDecember 12, 202492
Rocky Patel VintageVintageDecember 12, 202491
OlivaSeries VDecember 12, 202494
Room 101Johnny TobacconautDecember 12, 202492
West Tampa Tobacco Co.West Tampa BlackDecember 12, 202491
Rocky PatelSixtyDecember 12, 202495
Alec BradleyPost Emarbgo Blend Core B15December 12, 202491
Montecristo1935 Anniversary NicaraguaDecember 12, 202493
TatuajeHavana VI VerocuDecember 12, 202492
WarpedMaestro Del TiempoDecember 12, 202493
Ultimate CigarsBatch No.10July 17, 202491
La SirenaMexican MermaidJuly 11, 202494
La AuroraHors D'AgeSeptember 14, 202393
La AuroraPreferidos 1903 EmeraldJuly 13, 202386
ArtistaMidnightJuly 13, 202392
AladinoCorojoJuly 13, 202390
Esteban CarrerasMr. BrownstoneJuly 13, 202392
J.C. NewmanDiamond Crown No. 5July 13, 202394
My FatherFlor de las Antillas SungrownJuly 13, 202388
MacanudoInspirado Tercio-AgedJuly 13, 202389
La AuroraCorojo 1962July 13, 202388
KristoffCameroon MatadorJuly 13, 202391
IllusioneSingulare OrigenJuly 13, 202391
Don DoroteoEl LegadoJuly 13, 202395
CohibaRivieraJuly 13, 202395
Arturo FuenteCasa Cuba Doble CincoJuly 13, 202392
Aganorsa LeafLa Validacion HabanoJuly 13, 202391
Aging RoomRare CollectionJuly 13, 202395
CohibaRivieraJuly 12, 202395
TatuajeEscasosJuly 10, 202394
DavidoffAniversario Double RJune 14, 202392
ArtistaColorado—92

Latest

Style

New Release Limited Edition Omega 007

0
.er-omega *{box-sizing:border-box!important}.er-omega .er-inner{max-width:820px!important;margin:auto!important;padding:0 22px!important}.er-omega img{display:block!important;max-width:100%!important;height:auto!important;margin:0 auto!important;border:0!important}.er-omega .er-photo{max-width:600px!important;width:100%!important;margin:28px auto 12px!important}.er-omega...
Cover Interviews

Curtis “50 Cent” Jackson – Winter Collectors Edition 2026 – Pre-Order your Collectors Issue

0
ENTHUSIAST REPORT MAGAZINE Pre-Order The Latest Issue   Discover the latest in...
Food and Drink

SkinnyDipped’s Val & Breezy Griffith Reinventing the Classic Wafer While Staying True to Their Roots

0
      ENTHUSIAST REPORT • FOUNDERS SkinnyDipped’s Val & Breezy Griffith   Reinventing the...
Cigar Interviews

The Mountain Behind the Leaf – Exclusive Interview with Jacob Yfrach

0
      ENTHUSIAST REPORT • FEATURE The Mountain Behind the Leaf   High in the...

Trending

Cigar Interviews

“Do Not Join Privada” A talk with Brian Desind and Lincoln Salazar – PCC Launches Members ONLY

0
After my 15 years working in the premium cigar...
Cover Interviews

ORDER YOUR COLLECTOR’S EDITION – THE PRINCE OF DARKNESS – OZZY OSBOURNE

0
YOUR COMPLIMENTARY DIGITAL EDITION!    ORDER YOUR PRINTED COPY NOW! LIMITED...
Cigar Education

The Ultimate Guide on Cigar Humidity

0
You will notice there are several factors to consider...
Fashion

A $892,500 Suit! The Stuart Hughes Diamond Edition: The Pinnacle of Luxury in Men’s Fashion

0
The Stuart Hughes Diamond Edition: The Pinnacle of Luxury...
Events

Newport Beach Cigar, Wine & Spirits Tasting 2025 – Tickets

0
Did you enjoy 2024's event at the Hyatt in...
Enthusiast Report
Enthusiast Reporthttps://enthusiastreport.com

Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Rating

Donovan Norfleet -
Each cigar is blind tasted on a 100-point scaling system and categorized by ratings up to 100. Only cigars that score over an 85...
Read more

J. C. Newman Perla del Mar Shade Rating

Donovan Norfleet -
Each cigar is blind tasted on a 100-point scaling system and categorized by ratings up to 100. Only cigars that score over an 85...
Read more

My Fathers Cigars Flor de las Antillas Sungrown Rating

Enthusiast Report -
Each cigar is blind tasted on a 100-point scaling system and categorized by ratings up to 100. Only cigars that score over an 85...
Read more

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!

Looking for something?

Categories

CigarsEventsInterviewsMotorsSpiritsWine

Most recent

Most popular

Stay Updated

© Enthusiast Report 2024 - All rights reserved. In Enthusiast Report, we feature a modern, broader vision of luxury and lifestyle, a camaraderie that we all share as Enthusiasts of the finer things in life.